When starting a company, knowing the fundamental documents that frame its identity and operations is crucial. Among these are the Memorandum of Association (MOA) and the Articles of Association (AOA), which are foundational pillars. They are not only a legal requirement but also a key tool in defining the company's purpose, structure, and management framework. Though they function together, they have different roles. Therefore, it is essential to get a good understanding of them.

The MOA refers to a company's charter, where its identity and purpose are established. In this context, the MOA outlines the company's objectives, the scope of operations, and its relationship with external parties such as shareholders, creditors, and regulatory authorities. The MOA ensures that the scope of the company's activities is defined, thus avoiding activities that would be beyond the company's stated purposes.

On the other hand, the AOA provides an internal management and administration perspective of the company. It would detail rules, regulations, and procedures governing the everyday operations of the company, including provisions for director appointments, processes for making decisions, calling shareholder meetings, and their voting rights, among others on internal governance matters. The MOA and AOA are the basic frameworks that provide the basis for a company's operations. The former explains the "what" and "why" of the business, whereas the latter explains the "how."

The MOA gives a broad framework, while the AOA provides specific guidelines for running the company effectively. For entrepreneurs, investors, and stakeholders, understanding these differences is of prime importance. A clear understanding of these roles ensures that all parties involved in the business adhere to legal frameworks, safeguard the interests of stakeholders, and, more importantly, ensure that the company prospers overall. This article explains how MOA and AOA are different and significant for forming a company's legal and operational structure.

Memorandum of Association

Meaning
MOA is a legal document created during the registration and creation of a business. A MOA is a representation of a company's charter. It outlines the goals for which the company was founded and the relationship between the company and its shareholders. Only the operations listed in the MOA may be carried out by the company. As a result, the MOA establishes limits on what the corporation can and cannot do. The company's acts will be deemed ultra vires and therefore void if they go beyond the parameters of the Memorandum of Agreement.

The MOA contains a full description of the company's whole organizational structure. By paying the Registrar of Companies the required fees, anyone can obtain the company's memorandum of agreement. Therefore, before signing a contract with the company, it is beneficial for shareholders, creditors, and anybody else interacting with the business to understand the fundamental rights and authority of the organization.

Additionally, the MOA's contents assist potential shareholders in making the best choice when contemplating an investment in the business. A minimum of two subscribers must sign the memorandum of agreement for a private limited business and seven members for a public limited company.

Features of MOA

MOA is a significant legal document that describes a company's constitution, authority, and range of operations. It forms the basis for incorporating a business and is mandated by law in the majority of nations. The company's name, kind, state or nation, and incorporation date are all listed in the MOA. It serves as a public record, guaranteeing openness and enabling prospective creditors or investors to review the company's goals and legal basis before engaging in business transactions.

The company's activities are described in the Object Clause, with Main Objects outlining the main business and Ancillary Objects stating the actions required to achieve these goals. Any activity that goes beyond these boundaries is deemed excessive and may be deemed invalid. The MOA also limits the company's power, stating that any activity outside the specified objects would be considered ultra vires and invalid.

The Liability Clause establishes the liability of shareholders, with limited liability companies restricting liability to the unpaid amount of shares held and unlimited companies having unlimited liability for the company's debts. An essential document that describes a company's existence, operations, and authority is the MOA. It describes the company's original subscribers, authorized share capital, and operating legal structure.

As mandated by the Companies Act or other laws in the majority of jurisdictions, the MOA also aids in guaranteeing adherence to legal and regulatory obligations. Additionally, the MOA serves as a roadmap for the corporation's operations, including precise rules for financial affairs, corporate governance, and business operations. Depending on the jurisdiction, special resolution and shareholder and regulatory authority permission may be needed for changes to certain sections. The MOA also specifies the company's registered office, which affects the regulatory framework and establishes the business's jurisdiction.

By limiting the company's operations to those specified in the Object Clause and guaranteeing that shareholders are solely held accountable for the amount they invest in the business, the rights and interests of shareholders are likewise protected by the MOA. To sum up, the MOA is a crucial and thorough agreement that describes the company's existence, operations, and authority. It guarantees that the business functions within the law establishes its goals, and restricts its authority, safeguarding the business and outside stakeholders (Introduction to Company Law, n.d.).

Contents of MOA

1. Name Clause
   The Name Clause specifies the official name of the business. This name needs to be distinct from that of other registered entities. Also, the name must adhere to any legal standards set down by the jurisdiction's corporate regulating authority. For instance, a limited liability company's name must conclude with "Limited" or "Ltd.". This signifies that the members' responsibility is restricted to the amount owed on their shares.
   
   This provision guarantees the legal recognition and protection of the company's identity. A company is an artificial person and, therefore, it requires a name to establish its identity. Any name that is not deemed unwanted by the Central Government may be used by a business; however, a name will be considered undesirable if it is the same as or very similar to the name originally used by an existing company to register.
   
   A name will be taken as undesirable if it is so identical with or so nearly resembles the name of an existing company as to be calculated to deceive the public or to lead the public to confusion and it will be taken to be calculated to deceive the public or to lead the public to confusion when it suggests that the company adopting it is in some way connected with the existing company while in reality there is no connection between them.
   
   Similarly, in Society of Motor Manufacturers & Traders Ltd. v. Motor Manufacturers and Traders Mutual Assurance Ltd., the name of one company was 'Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders Ltd. and the other company was "Motor Manufacturers and Traders Mutual Assurance Ltd." and thus the words "Motor Manufacturers and Traders" were common in the name of both the companies. The court held that the name was not undesirable because their business was different. The plaintiff company was a trade protection society while the defendant company was an insurance company and, therefore, a reasonable man was not likely to conclude that the defendant company was connected with the plaintiff company.
   
   The name chosen must not be the one prohibited by statutes. By the Emblems and Name (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950, it is illegal to incorporate a business that uses the name, emblem, or official of the Government of India or any State's U.N.O. or W.H.O. without the consent of the Central Government or any government officer who may be authorized in this regard by the Central connection with a Government or a municipality. Only in extraordinary cases are names permitted to contain the terms Imperial, Commonwealth, National, or International.
    
2. Registered Clause
   The physical address of the company's registered office, which serves as the official address for all correspondence and legal notices about the business, is provided by the Registered Office Clause. The nation in which the business is formed is where the registered office must be located. The company's registered office must be open to the public and recognized by the government, even though its actual headquarters or commercial premises may differ.
   
   Court notifications, legal papers, and other official correspondence are sent to this address. The memorandum of every company must state the State in which its registered office is to be situated. A company is required to have such an office from the date on which the company begins to carry business incorporation, whichever is earlier. All communications or within 30 days after the company is addressed to its registered office. Notice of the situation of the registered office and every change therein must be given within 30 days after the date of the incorporation of the company or after the date of the change, to the Registrar. The place of relevant fact is to be taken into account in determining the jurisdiction of the court.
    
3. Object Clause
   An essential component of the MOA that describes a company's goals and range of operations is the Object Clause. It acts as a safeguard to make sure the business stays within the bounds of the law and achieves its goals. The corporation must modify the MOA with the consent of shareholders and regulatory bodies if it wants to carry out operations beyond its declared goals. Ancillary Objects, which are auxiliary activities that support the main objects, and Main Objects, which are the major business the firm is established to conduct, are usually included in this section. Stakeholder objections or legal repercussions might result from going over these boundaries.
   
   The purpose for which the prospective company is being founded must be stated in the memorandum. According to the Companies (Amendment) Act of 1965, a company's objects clause should simply state its goals if it was founded before this amendment. However, if it was established after the amendment, the objects clause needs to be split into two clauses (Sánchez, 2021).
    
4. Liability Clause
   The Liability Clause outlines the degree to which the company's members, or shareholders, are responsible for the obligations of the business.
   
   There are two categories of member liability:
   
   • Limited Responsibility: The liability of shareholders of a limited corporation (by shares) is capped to the amount owed on each share.
   • Unlimited responsibility: In some situations, members' responsibility cannot be restricted, and they might be held personally responsible for the debts of the business.
   For the protection and comprehension of shareholders, this provision makes clear the amount of risk they assume if the business has financial difficulties.
   This clause states the nature of the liability of the members of the company. In the case of an unlimited company, this clause should be omitted. MOA of a company limited by shares or guarantee must state the liability of its members is limited. [Section 13(2)]
    
5. Capital Clause
   The authorized share capital of the business, or the total value of the shares the business may issue to shareholders, is described in the Capital Clause. The MOA must specify the number of shares and their nominal values. The permitted capital is split up into shares of a certain value. The approved share capital limits the amount of money that the firm can raise. The corporation must expand its authorized capital by filing with the appropriate authorities and passing a special resolution if it wants to raise additional money.
   
   The capital clause clarifies the company's financial structure and the quantity of shares that can be distributed to shareholders. If a business has a share capital, the capital clause of its MOA must specify how much share capital it will be registered with and how it will be divided into shares of a certain amount. Since a corporation limited by shares must have a share capital, the capital clause must be included in its memorandum. It is not needed for a company limited by guarantee to have a share capital, but if it does, the capital clause must be included in its memorandum.
   
   A corporation limited by guarantee does not have to include a capital provision in its memorandum if it does not have share capital. In the case of an unlimited company the capital clause is not required to be included in its memorandum (Jain, 2020)
    
6. Subscription Clause
   A declaration made by the original signatories to the memorandum usually the company's founding members is included in this section. These subscribers subscribe for at least one share each and declare their desire to start the business. The names of the first shareholders and the number of shares they committed to purchase are listed in the association clause, which signifies the formation of the business. Because it formally establishes the business and guarantees that it has the bare minimum of subscribers typically two or more for private companies for legal recognition, the association clause is essential.
   
   At least seven people must subscribe to a company's memorandum if it is a public limited company, and at least two people must subscribe if it is a private business. The memorandum must be signed by each subscriber in front of a minimum of one witness who will attest to his signature. Each subscriber must put the number of shares they own besides their name if the firm has share capital; no subscriber may accept fewer than one share.

Articles of Association

Meaning
The way a business issues shares, distributes dividends, examines its financial records, and grants voting rights is specified in its AOA. This collection of guidelines may be thought of as the company's user handbook. Although the content differs depending on the jurisdiction, this document has a universal format and generally summarizes. The next stage of a company's establishment is the creation of the AOA. All companies, except those limited by shares, must submit it to the Registrar for registration. A public corporation limited by shares does not have to have its own AOA, although it is not required to have them. It usually does. The AOA, however, may be seen as a set of guidelines for a company's internal management. They serve as guidelines and bylaws for the company's internal administration. The provisions concerning the appointment, qualifications, and authority of directors, managing directors, managing agents, secretaries, etc. are thus contained in the articles. Additionally, they specify the rights of various shareholder classes. They offer guidelines for the company's meetings. Therefore, the rules and regulations that the whole internal administration of the organization is based on are contained in the articles. The articles specify the governing body's responsibilities, rights, and authority about the company as a whole. They also specify the manner and format in which the company's operations are to be conducted and how modifications to the internal rules of the organization may occasionally be made.

Features of AOA

A company's AOA, which specifies its policies for internal affairs, management, and operations, is an essential document. It describes the functions, duties, and authority of directors, shareholders, and other members and is an element of the company's constitution. The rights and obligations of shareholders, such as the ability to vote, receive dividends, and transfer shares, are also described in the Articles.

The general structure and governance of a business depend on these papers. The board's structure, including the nomination and removal of directors, their responsibilities, and the process for board meetings, is described in the Articles. They also specify the nomination of officials such as the CEO or company secretary, as well as the duties and responsibilities of directors.

The frequency, quorum criteria, voting methods, and resolution kinds (ordinary or extraordinary) of general meetings are all outlined in the Articles. They also specify the voting methods and the bare minimum of shareholders required for decisions. The procedure for issuing new shares and transferring existing ones is described in the Articles, along with limitations on transfer approval and the company's authority to reject a transfer. They may also provide guidelines for reserves and retained earnings, as well as how the business will share its profits, including the announcement and disbursement of dividends.

A company's Articles specify how its basic regulations can be changed, usually requiring a special resolution for any modifications. Additionally, they protect directors, officers, and employees from personal responsibility for acts they conduct in good faith while carrying out their responsibilities on the company's behalf by providing indemnification clauses. A company's borrowing capabilities, including the board's ability to get loans and shareholder approval, are outlined in the Articles.

They also specify the dissolution or winding up processes, such as the distribution of assets following the settlement of obligations and the board's borrowing power. Provisions for resolving disputes between directors, shareholders, or the business possibly through mediation or arbitration may be included in the articles. They could also talk about other issues about pay, including employee share plans and advantages like ESOPs.

Differences Between MOA and AOA

Key Contents of MOA

• Name Clause: The name of the company, which shall be "Limited" if the company is public limited, while in the case of private limited, it ends with "Private Limited."
• Registered Office Clause: Where the company is situated.
• Object Clause: Main goals or objects, the nature of business which the company wishes to engage into. It tells us how big the scope of activities is in a particular business.
• Liability Clause: The liability of the members of the company, which could be limited (limited liability) or unlimited.
• Capital Clause: The amount of capital the company can raise and the number of shares into which it is divided.
• Association Clause: A statement of the subscribers to the MOA, agreeing to form the company (Roach & L, 2022).

Key Contents of AOA

• Share Capital and Debits: Rights and obligations pertaining to shares of the company (Voting rights, right to dividends).
• Meetings: Provisions on convening and holding of Annual General Meeting and Board Meeting.
• Directors Powers and Authorities: Appointment, removal, authorities, and responsibilities of the directors.
• Transferability of Shares: Regulations related to the transfer and transmission of the shares.
• Dividend Distribution: The procedure and terms for the distribution of dividends among shareholders.
• Borrowing Powers: The company's powers to borrow funds.
• Indemnity and Insurance: Provisions regarding indemnification of directors and officers.
• Winding Up: Procedures to be followed in case the company is dissolved or wound up (Gupta and V. R, 2022).

Binding Effect

Binding Effect of MOA

• Binding the company and outsiders: The MOA marks out the relationship between a company and the outside world. It is a public document that, after its registration, binds a company and its shareholders together, and outsiders are not an exception.
• Binding on the Company: The company needs to work under the authorities provided by the MOA. For example, if the company's object clause restricts its activities, it will not engage in such activities.
• Binding on the Shareholders: Shareholders must respect the provisions in the MOA. Objections regarding any clause or limitation cannot override the MOA once they become members.
• Binding on Third Parties: As a public document filed with the Registrar of Companies, the MOA is a source for third parties to gain insights into a company's powers (Trapotsi et al., 2022).

Binding Effect of AOA

1. Binding on the Company, Shareholders, and Directors:
   • The company must adhere to the rules in the AOA regarding internal administration.
   • Shareholders must follow provisions related to share transfers, voting rules, etc.
   • Directors must act in line with the AOA's management structure, powers, and duties.
2. Binding Among Internal Parties:
   • The Company and Its Shareholders: The AOA's provisions are binding between the company and the shareholders.
   • Shareholders and Other Shareholders: Shareholders are governed by AOA provisions regarding relationships with one another, like share transfers.
   • Directors and the Company: The AOA defines directors' powers and duties about the company.
3. Binding on Third Parties: The AOA does not impose direct obligations on third parties. However, in certain instances, such as forming contracts, it may indirectly affect them (Goel and V, 2024).

Alteration

Alteration of Memorandum of Association
The MOA can be altered only by a special resolution passed by the shareholders. The alteration should not offend any law or the aims of the company. Some clauses in the MOA, such as the Object Clause, Capital Clause, and Name Clause, are subject to specific legal restrictions; hence any alteration to them often involves the approval of regulatory authorities such as the Registrar of Companies (ROC).
xcxc Procedures

1. Special Resolution: It requires a special resolution of the shareholders in a general meeting. Two-thirds of the shareholders' vote will be required to pass this special resolution.
2. Filing with Registrar: Within a given period, the altered MOA needs to be filed with the ROC by the company.
3. Government Sanction: Some alterations may be subject to central government sanction or the approval of the Registrar for the alteration to take place.

Examples of Alteration of MOA

• Change of name.
• Change in object clause: Increase or diminution in scope of activities by the company.
• Enhancement or reduction of authorized capital (Bhargava & A, 2023).

Alteration of AOA

Changes can be made by special resolution of its members. Its alteration shall not be prohibited in any law and existing laws. It should also not go contrary to anything in the MOA that forms the boundary of doing business by that company.

Steps Involved

1. Special Resolution: The shareholders shall at a meeting pass a special resolution with a majority vote of two-thirds.
2. Filing with Registrar: Once the special resolution has been passed, the new AOA is filed with the ROC; however, it is not always mandatory depending on the change. Most of the time, the new AOA becomes operational immediately when approved by the shareholders.

Examples

• Modification of the shareholder meetings rules, such as voting procedures, and quorum requirements.
• Change in directors' powers or the method for appointment or removal.
• Change in the dividend distribution policy or transfer rules of shares (Bhargava & A, 2023).

Breach

The MOA defines the scope, objectives of the company, and its relationships outside. Most breaches of the MOA usually deal with an abuse of power or acting beyond the scope of the objects stated within the document. The consequences might be very detrimental to the firm and all of its stakeholders. Whereas the AOA governs the internal rules and procedures of a company, covering matters concerning shareholders' rights, directorial duties, share transfer, voting procedure, etc. Most of the time, an AOA breach arises from the violation of these internal rules by failing to observe them as specified.

Breach of MOA

• The company is performing activities that fall beyond the scope of its object clause, or ultra vires acts.
• The company performs in a manner contrary to its capital structure or powers stipulated in the MOA.
• The company uses a name not agreed upon by the MOA's name clause.

Breach of AOA

• Violation of internal rules concerning shareholders' rights.
• Failure to adhere to directorial duties.
• Non-compliance with voting procedures or share transfer rules.

Nature:

A breach under the AOA arises whenever:

• The company, the directors, or the shareholders fail to observe the procedures set for holding the meetings. This can be quorum requirements or any other provisions.
• The company or its shareholders act in violation of share transfer, distribution of dividends, or appointment of directors.
• Directors and shareholders ignore or violate the rights of other shareholders or directors as contemplated under the AOA.

Consequences of Breach:

• Ultra Vires Acts: Anything done beyond the scope of the company's object clause, i.e., ultra vires, is deemed to be void and cannot be enforced. An agreement to provide services, for example, established by a business that was incorporated to produce goods, would be considered null and void as it would go against the goals of the business as stated during the formation process.
• Third-Party Reliance: Generally speaking, third parties dealing with the company are presumed to be aware of the MOA provisions. If they act outside those boundaries, they may have legal challenges. However, if the third party deals with the company in good faith and the company is acting within its apparent scope, it may still be protected.
• Legal Action: Breach of the MOA would lead to legal proceedings against the company including filing for damages or declaring acts ultra vires by the company. Ultra vires actions committed by a corporation can be challenged by shareholders.
• Liability: The company directors and officers can be held liable if their actions contradict the MOA, especially where there is a breach of fiduciary duties or beyond the powers provided for under the MOA (Madrunio & M. R, 2022).

Consequences of Breach (AOA Specific):

• Internal Litigation: Breach of the AOA mainly generates internal litigations within the company between shareholders and directors. For instance, if the company fails to follow the proper procedure regarding a call for an AGM, such shareholders will look for a remedy through litigations.
• Injunctions or Court Orders: It is possible that the party affected by the AOA may apply for a court order to force compliance. A shareholder may seek an injunction should they be wrongfully refused the right to vote on a resolution at a shareholders' meeting.
• Damages: In case of a breach of the AOA, the parties may be compensated for damages if they prove that there was a loss incurred by the breach. For example, if a shareholder is illegally excluded from a meeting, they may claim compensation for the loss incurred as a result of the said action (Suresh & J, 2022).

Remedies:

Suits against the company to have the act declared to be outside its powers. In some instances, the company is permitted to ratify certain ultra vires acts if the MOA allows it or if it gets the approval of the shareholders through a resolution (Madrunio & M. R, 2022).

• Compensation: The company or the directors may be liable to compensate shareholders for any loss incurred in the event of a breach of the AOA.
• Specific Performance against Shareholders or Directors: Specific performance may be ordered for compliance with the AOA's provisions by shareholders or directors.
• Rescission or Annulment of Acts: If acts done are contrary to the AOA, they can be rescinded or annulled by the court.
• Ratification: Shareholders can ratify the breach under some circumstances if the AOA permits it. It will regularize an act that otherwise was in breach of articles (Suresh & J, 2022).

Conclusion
Understanding the differences between the MOA and AOA is essential to any player in the corporate world, be it entrepreneurs, investors, or legal practitioners. While interlinked, these two documents have a different purpose, which plays a crucial role in forming, governing, and running a company. MOA becomes the charter for the company, stating objectives, scope of activities, and relationships with the external world: regulators, creditors, shareholders, etc. The MOA provides a basic foundation with transparency and proper boundaries around the company's operations.

Without an MOA, no company has any legal identity to operate or attract any external trust or investment. Conversely, the AOA explains the internal affairs of the company and how its internal procedures and regulations work to govern the daily affairs of the company. It can be considered a rule book for the directors and the shareholders to run the affairs of the company without interruptions. The MOA talks about "what" the company is and "why" it exists, but the AOA explains "how" the company runs its affairs and manages the processes within.

Together, these documents make a solid framework for the existence and governance of a company. Together, they bridge the corporate operations' external and internal dimensions while complementing each other in their entirety. For entrepreneurs, it is about the clarity these documents provide regarding compliance with the legal frameworks and laying down a strong foundation for growth.

To stakeholders, they bring about transparency, predictability, and a safety net for their interests. In a nutshell, the MOA and AOA are necessary elements of the corporate framework. Having a proper understanding of them and their differences helps smoothen the workflow of business operations as well as strengthen the confidence of everyone involved in the company's journey toward success.

References:

1. Bhargava, A. (2023). Copyright Law and Artificial Intelligence Generated Works: Ownership and Liability. Issue 2 Indian JL & Legal Rsch., 5, 1
2. Goel, V. (2024). Demystifying Legal Due Diligence: A Primer for Assessing Indian Private Companies. Available at SSRN 4843162
3. Gupta, P. (2021). Shareholder's Agreement and Articles of Association: A Power Struggle. Issue 3 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 4, 1239
4. Gupta, V. R. (2022). Difference between MOA and AOA. Issue 6 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 5, 1920.
5. Introduction to Company Law. (n.d.). Google Books. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=JcjLDwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=features+of+memorandum+of+association+company+law&ots=y5--qXLv2p&sig=J3CrRm_pXc-izt0fbSO07BJljY8
6. Jain, S. (2020). Principal documents of a company: memorandum and articles. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3902356
7. Madrunio, M. R. (2022). Move structure and terms of agreement reflecting legal value in memoranda of agreement on academic partnerships (MOA). Philippine Journal of Linguistics, 51, 87-113.
8. Pundale, N. (2023). Analysing Shareholders Agreement Encompassing Restrictions on Free Transferability of Shares and Their Enforceability with Regards to the Articles of Association. Issue 3 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 6, 1455.
9. Roach, L. (2022). Company law. Oxford University Press.
10. Sánchez, M. a. J. (2021). The Objects clause and the Ultra vires doctrine. In SpringerBriefs in law (pp. 95–102). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-88838-1_6
11. Shukla, V. (2022). Section 3 of the Companies Act, 2013: Formation of Company. Issue 4 Indian JL & Legal Rsch., 4, 1.
12. Suresh, J. (2022). Memorandum and Articles of Association: An Analysis of Their Role in Corporate Governance as Foundation of a Company. Issue 6 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 5, 539.
13. Trapotsi, M. A., Hosseini-Gerami, L., & Bender, A. (2022). Computational analyses of mechanism of action (MoA): data, methods and integration. RSC chemical biology, 3(2), 170-200.

Also Read:

• Memorandum of Association (MOA) and Articles of Association (AOA): Analysing the Differences